Summary
In her first blog in this mini-series, Michele Peters, Associate Professor from the University of Oxford, shared findings from a research project that focused on patient harm in the NHS.
In this second blog she delves deeper into research into how people responded after healthcare related harm, and the factors that influenced their decision-making. Michele concludes by sharing four recommendations to help people recover and rebuild trust.
Content
This study looked at what happens to people after they experienced harm in the National Health Service (NHS) and how they decide what to do next. The research team wanted to understand people’s feelings, actions, support received, and the barriers people face when trying to get help or justice. Two groups were compared:
People who took formal action (made an official complaint or started legal proceedings)
People who did not take formal action
How the study was done?
The team carried out interviews with 49 people from different regions across Great Britain and different ethnic groups, and social backgrounds.
The age of interview participants ranged from 18 to over 65. Around 60% were women. Twenty-nine people did not take formal action and 20 took formal action.
What harm did people report?
The harm people described varied. Some had physical harm, such as injuries, infections, or worsening of their condition. Others experienced emotional harm including trauma, anxiety, or loss of trust in healthcare. Some experienced delays in care that made their health worse. Some harm happened suddenly whilst others developed slowly over months or years through poor communication or lack of access to treatment.
People’s reactions after being harmed by healthcare were often intense and long-lasting. Many felt disbelief and distress at first, then anger, confusion, and sadness.
What did people do after the harm?
Almost everyone tried at first to raise concerns informally with NHS staff. They wanted someone to explain what happened, apologise, or offer help to recover. Sadly, most said these early efforts went nowhere. Staff often seemed defensive, dismissive, or unavailable. Few people received meaningful explanations or support. Instead, they felt ignored or even blamed. Those reactions made emotional wounds worse and left people feeling abandoned.
What affected people’s decisions to take formal action?
Most people thought about complaining or taking legal action, but few did, usually due to a combination of different reasons. Researchers looked at ability, possibility and motivation to act between people who took or did not take formal action.

Money was rarely a main reason for formal action. In fact, some people who pursued legal cases felt guilty, worrying they were taking funds away from the NHS.

What do the findings mean?
Across all participants, a clear pattern emerged: people wanted understanding, honesty, and support, not punishment. But the NHS’s responses often made things worse. Dismissive or defensive behaviour deepened people’s distress, sometimes leading to long-term distrust of healthcare.
People from marginalised or minority backgrounds faced extra challenges including less confidence, less support, and more fear of being ignored or treated unfairly. They were less likely to complain and more likely to withdraw from care altogether.
What needs to change?
The study suggests that the current system for handling patient harm in the NHS isn’t working well. Formal complaints and legal systems can sometimes identify what happened but they often don’t meet most people’s emotional or practical needs. Other support services like PALS (Patient Advice and Liaison Service) have too few staff, limited opening hours and are thought to lack independence.
To help people recover and rebuild trust, the researchers recommend:
More compassionate communication – staff should listen, apologise sincerely, and acknowledge harm instead of being defensive.
Tailored support for recovery – emotional, physical, and practical help should be offered early.
Inclusive services – people from marginalised groups need easier ways to raise concerns.
Rather than leaving formal complaints or legal action as the only way for harmed patients to get answers and support with recovery from harm, the NHS should create safe spaces for open talks between staff and patients that can identifying their needs and also help staff to learn from what went wrong.
By improving how the NHS responds, patients can recover better, and staff and health services can learn from what went wrong. This could reduce complaints, restore faith in the NHS, and prevent future harm.
Contact Michele for more information - [email protected]
Recommended Comments
Create an account or sign in to comment