Derby doctor who put patients at risk has eighth tribunal in nine years

A Derby doctor who has been the subject of eight tribunals in less than nine years has been sanctioned for a further four months. Dr Anatta Nergui was originally found guilty of misconduct in 2014 and has been found to have not fully reflected on the severity of his offending in six different hearings since.

The psychiatrist was suspended by the Medical Practitioner Tribunal Service (MPTS) in 2014 for running a website and blog which offered incorrect medical advice to those who got in contact with him. In 20 of 22 cases, he was found to have failed to recommend that the patient saw a doctor or psychiatrist, and failed to recommend a counselling or psychotherapy course in 30 cases, among other complaints, which put patients at "significant risk of harm".

The latest tribunal aimed at assessing his fitness to practice, held in March 2022, has imposed a further four months of conditions on him, after the MPTS found that "despite there being a low risk of repetition, the remediation had not yet been completed", according to the chair of the tribunal, Jetinder Shergill.

In the MPTS determination, released on Thursday (March 17), Mr Shergill said: "While the tribunal was satisfied that there is sufficient evidence Dr Nergui is a competent and safe doctor, there remains a lingering concern that he did not appreciate the findings made against him from the patient’s perspective and/or did not express this in a clear, cogent manner. The tribunal considered that Dr Nergui might have benefitted from seeking feedback from a trusted colleague or mentor, reflecting on what went wrong and setting out his thought processes on avoiding similar risk.

"In short, the self-reflection has led Dr Nergui down a restricted path of understanding, leading him to focus on the legal aspects of the process and semantics rather than the primary issue which was one of patient safety. If he had sought the input of a third party, it may have led to him developing an alternative view rather than the binary approach that he has adopted. This left the tribunal with the view that whilst there has been some insight, remediation is not yet complete."

Read full story

Source: Derbyshire Live, 18 March 2022