Jump to content

Head of NHS inquiry warns other families could be victims of cover-ups


The chairman of an inquiry that has confirmed a 20-year cover-up over the avoidable death of a baby has warned there are other families who may have suffered a similar ordeal.

Publishing the findings of his investigation into the 2001 death of Elizabeth Dixon, Dr Bill Kirkup said he wanted to see action taken to prevent harmed families having to battle for years to get answers.

Dr Kirkup, who has been involved in multiple high-profile investigations of NHS failures in recent years, said: “There has been considerable difficulty in establishing investigations, where events are regarded as historic. I don't like the term historic investigations. I think that these things remain current for the people who've suffered harm, until they're resolved, it’s not historic for them.  

“There has been significant reluctance to look at a variety of cases. Mr and Mrs Dixon were courageous and very persistent and they were given help by others and were successful in securing the investigation and it worries me that other people haven't been.

“I do think we should look at how we can establish a proper mechanism that will make sure that such cases are heard."

“It's impossible to rule out there being other people who are in a similar position. In fact, I know of some who are. I think it's as important for them that they get heard, and that they get things that should have been looked at from the start looked at now, if that's the best that we can do.”

Read full story

Source: The Independent, 27 November 2020

2 Comments


Recommended Comments

This is so sad, I feel desperately sad for Elizabeth Dixon and the family & everyone affected by cover ups of the death of a child .

It is not an isolated incident. The case of Robbie Powell has been subject to a 30 year cover up and remains unresolved. It was Robbie's father Will who first identified the lack of a legal hashtag#dutyofcandour. To this day there is no individual duty of candour. Papers labelled this 'a doctor's right to lie'.

As a clinician I am appalled. 

I should add, this isn't just about doctors, it's all clinicians. I remain deeply disappointed in my profession - #Nursing -for not speaking out.

No #nurse leaders seem interested. I am pleased to be able to teach on this, at least I can do something. #learningfromdeaths #LeDeR

  • 1 reactions so far
Link to comment

I'm greatly heartened by these comments. Also sad that clinicians with integrity can be badly affected by the profession closing ranks. I can only wonder at the dreadful effect on individuals who really care but dare not speak out - they are surely harmed,  as are the victims. I think you would find that patient advocates, and especially 'radical' patient advocates, did not want to find themselves on such a journey. Having raised their heads above the parapet they then feel driven to continue trying to bring about change - because barriers to openness and justice are embedded in the system. I'm not just referring to unnecessarry deaths. Thank you Steve Turner.

  • 2 reactions so far
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...